Tech blogger Jason Calacanis recently wrote a blog post declaring Facebook Bankruptcy. Unfortunately, he’s turned comments off.
The crux of his argument seems to be this:
You spend so much time checking off what you’ll do that you never do anything.
The graphic he displays shows him being overwhelmed with application invites.
In support of him, I’ve received 2 or 3 applications requests that I’ve been avoiding like the plague (Zombies, Werewolves, and other mythical creatures). But Calacanis doens’t get it. How many of us have 150+ pending friend requests? The only way this is possible is for the average person is if you’re incredibly popular, told people to invite you and haven’t logged into Facebook for 2 years. I’m still at 80 friends myself despite all the networking I’ve been doing as of late.
More importantly, the issue at hand here is who you choose to accept in your social network and what you choose to hear from them. It’s almost like making shady friends and lamenting that relationship when the cops come knocking on your door. On Facebook, any friend who spams me with invite request either will be dialed down or removed. Personally, I’ve only added people I know as friends and have only lately added acquaintances. There’s a rare breed of people (tech bloggers) who will open up their network like a downtown street-walker.
I’m not sure if Calacanis is calling for attention by declaring something ridiculous but I was glad to read that Scoble responded with a post titled Calacanis Can’t Keep Up With Facebook. He illustrates my point by saying:
Media creation also means I need to be a professional networker. That’s why I go to TechCrunch parties — to find great people to interview. Last night I collected a stack of business cards. Those people get invited to join Facebook. Why? Facebook is the new business card AND the new media distribution network. Watch what’s happening with video inside Facebook. Watch what’s happening with applications.
edit:
Calacanis has a follow-up post showing how out-of-touch he really is titled Social Network Exhaustion. In it he says:
are we creating a social system to communicate with each other at a distance because the reality of creating and maintaining that social networking face-to-face is, well, scary?
Ok. So this is a question coming from an “Enterpreneur in Action” at Sequoia Capital, a VC firm that’s investing in companies like LinkedIn and YouTube. Couldn’t the same question be asked of those two companies?
Calacanis is just showing us how much outside the mainstream he is. Why do I use Facebook? There are several reasons. It facilitates interaction with my friends through online means. Yes, I could call my friends, have them from LA, Boston, Paris, and the South Bay and then show them old digital pictures from when we were in college. I suppose many of them wouldn’t show up. Instead, I can just publish them on Facebook.
How can a question like this be posed from someone whose most recent successful venture was based on blogs?? That, I don’t get.